Snippet from Kan Broadcast of the hostages' release in Gaza City (video clip)

In a spectacle blending propaganda, resilience, and the grim realities of war, the release of four Israeli hostages from Hamas captivity on January 25 shocked the world. This calculated display, choreographed by Hamas and broadcast live, painted a vivid picture of a group desperate to assert dominance amidst devastation, even as Israel witnessed the return of its brave soldiers after 16 harrowing months in captivity.

A Stage Set Among Ruins

The backdrop for this meticulously staged event was the shattered landscape of Gaza City, reduced to rubble after 15 months of relentless conflict. Amid the ruins, a platform was erected, designed to convey Hamas’ supposed control over the enclave. The images, captured by Al Jazeera—whose broadcasts have been banned in Israel since mid-2024—were instantly disseminated, dominating Israeli airwaves and public spaces like Hostage Square in Tel Aviv. Citizens gathered, stunned by the audacity and theatrics of the event, where four young women stood calm and defiant against their captors' sinister narrative.

The Soldiers’ Poised Defiance

Daniella Gilboa, Naama Levy, Karina Ariev, and Liri Albag, ages ranging from 19 to 20, were anything but subdued. Despite their months of hardship, they exuded an aura of strength. Dressed in olive-green jumpsuits adorned with badges, their smiles and raised thumbs sent an unmistakable message of resilience. These young women, abducted in the early hours of October 7, 2023, from the Nahal Oz military base, had endured unimaginable challenges. Their confident demeanor during this orchestrated event, as reported by Israeli media, turned Hamas’ attempt at humiliation into a moment of quiet triumph.

“We showed them on the stage that we were not fazed,” one of the soldiers recounted to her family. “It had no impact on us. We are stronger than them.” The soldiers’ composure under such circumstances was a testament to their training, inner fortitude, and unity.

Behind the Scenes: A Harrowing Journey

The soldiers shared chilling details of their captivity with family and officials after their release. For 477 days, they were moved across Gaza, often confined to tunnels, sometimes in isolation, enduring deplorable conditions. Food shortages were common; at times, they were forced to cook for their captors or clean their facilities, only to be denied meals themselves. Hygiene was a distant luxury, with prolonged periods of no showers or sanitary provisions.

Naama Levy, a triathlete, found solace in her physical regimen, training alongside fellow hostage Doron Streinbrecher, who was released separately. “For body and soul,” they would tell themselves, finding strength in small routines. The women’s bond became their lifeline, with Liri Albag emerging as the group’s leader, negotiating with their captors on behalf of her peers.

A Propaganda Tool

Hamas’ use of the hostages as propaganda was relentless. The soldiers were given military-style uniforms and paraded before cameras, attempting to portray a veneer of control. Yet, their captors’ mockery—repeatedly referring to them as “the soldiers”—belied their insecurity. The captives’ apparent calmness during these staged events, and their refusal to be cowed, undermined Hamas’ narrative.

Glimmers of Hope Amid Darkness

Despite the grim conditions, the women found ways to maintain hope. They listened to Israeli radio, aware of their families’ unwavering efforts to secure their freedom. They even saw television coverage of protests advocating for their release, joking about the photos chosen by their families for campaign posters. These small glimpses of normalcy and connection to the outside world fortified their spirits.

However, not all moments were lighthearted. The absence of a fellow soldier, Agam Berger, who had been with them until days before their release, weighed heavily on them. “It was very hard for us when we realized she wasn’t coming with us,” they said, their voices tinged with sorrow.

Israel’s Calculated Response

As the release unfolded, Israeli security chiefs monitored the event with bated breath, concerned about the potential for chaos. Yet, the soldiers’ composed behavior flipped the script. “Their confidence turned humiliation into victory,” remarked an Israeli official, noting the profound psychological impact of their defiance.

Conclusion: A Symbol of Resilience

This hostage release was far more than a political transaction involving the exchange of 200 Palestinian prisoners. It was a vivid tableau of endurance, resilience, and the human spirit’s ability to rise above adversity. For Israel, it served as a reminder of the profound strength of its people. For Hamas, it was a stark demonstration of their own failures: even in the depths of captivity, their captives refused to be broken.

Sign Up For The Judean Newsletter

I agree with the Terms and conditions and the Privacy policy